Dock Street DUMBO opponents continue fight at City Hall

On Tuesday April 28th at 12:30 PM, a press conference will be held on the steps of City Hall to address the recent approval of the controversial Dock Street project by City Planning. 

Speakers will include Pulitzer Prize winning author and historian David McCullough, New York City Council Members David Yassky, Tony Avella and Bill de Blasio, representatives from preservation groups such as The Municipal Art Society, The Historic Districts Council, and The National Trust for Historic Preservation, civic groups DUMBO Neighborhood Alliance (DNA), Brooklyn Heights Association (BHA), and Fulton Ferry Landing Association (FFLA), as well as DUMBO residents and actors Skipp Sudduth (“Third Watch”, “Law and Order”) and Terry Kinney (“The Unusuals” and director of Broadway play “Reasons to Be Pretty”).

This event will act as the platform to address the truths and myths behind the project and the direct impact it will have on citizens of New York and around the world.

It is notable that, according to the New York Post, “officials for the company (Two Trees) — including the Walentases — have dished out $29,700 in campaign donations over this period to Councilwoman Melinda Katz and another $19,800 to Council Speaker Christine Quinn.  Katz, a local Democrat running for City Comptroller, heads the council’s land use committee, which must eventually decide whether to put Two Trees’ request for a necessary zoning change before the full council for final approval.”

Please write, email or call Council Speaker Christine Quinn to express your opposition.

Christine Quinn
224 West 30th St (Suite 1206)
New York, NY 10001
(212) 788-7210
email: cquinn@council.nyc.gov

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project

City Planning Gives Thumbs Up to Dock Street

Update: Adding Commissioner McRae’s statement and FFLA’s position.

An overflow crowd listened intently as the vote on Dock Street DUMBO took place yesterday at the City Planning Commission offices in lower Manhattan. The 11-2 vote in favor of a slightly modified proposal came as a disappointment to the local community association representatives that were present, including FFLA.  The token modification was a one-floor reduction of height in the tower, and a 21 foot lowering of only a 50 foot section of the Water Street wing.

In her statement objecting to the proposal, Commissioner Shirley McRae asked for all of the modifications in Borough President Marty Markowitz’s recommendation, including setbacks that would effectively move the tower section an additional 50 feet from the Bridge and reduce its girth. However, unlike the BP, she also stipulated that the tower height should be capped at 150 feet.

FFLA believes that the 70′ setback from Front Street (above 85′) and the reduction in tower height would be an obvious improvement over what CPC approved, but we further believe that the Water Street wing should be lowered in its entirety to 55′, the height of the Empire Stores, to preserve the stupendous views seen while walking down Old Fulton Street, looking under the Brooklyn Bridge at the sky and the Manhattan Bridge beyond. See photo example.

The project will now go before the Zoning and Land Use Committees of City Council, before being voted on by the full Council. Local Councilmembers David Yassky and Bill de Blasio continue to oppose the project, as well as CM Tony Avella.

Additional coverage can be found at NY1, NY Post, Brooklyn Daily Eagle.

Also, the Hollywood Reporter details the stars who are coming out against the Dock Street project. 

Please write, email or call Council Speaker Christine Quinn and Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s office to express your opposition.

Christine Quinn
224 West 30th St (Suite 1206)
New York, NY 10001
(212) 788-7210
email: cquinn@council.nyc.gov

Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg
City Hall
New York, NY 10007
email: http://www.nyc.gov/html/mail/html/mayor.html

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project

What Will the MTA Budget Cuts Mean to Fulton Ferry?

Last month, The MTA doomsday plan was voted in, but a rescue plan from Albany is still being worked on. See this recent article in Newsday for details.

If there is no rescue, the plan goes into effect on June 1st, with the bus cuts probably happening at the end of the month. 
 
This PDF shows the planned extension of the B67 bus to Fulton Landing to make up for the loss of the B25. Seems like some folks who now take the bus up the hill to the High Street A station might switch to the B67 bus to the York Street F station instead.

Leave a Comment

Filed under B25 bus service cuts

New Building Planned for Old Fulton Street

Application has been made to construct a new building at 9 Old Fulton, in the currently empty lot. This is within the FFL historic district, but since it is a new building next to an historic row of houses, the height and design will be extremely important.  The application was approved by the CB2 Land Use Committee over several no votes; a motion to approve without a rooftop “mezzanine”  was defeated by one vote.  

The design has been described to us as a penthouse “cube” on top of the 4-story building. We have concerns that the bulkhead will encroach on the view of the Bridge, will be seen from the street, and will be inconsistent with the historic character of this row of houses, whose history extends back to the 1830′s.  

A Public viewing of the plans will be held at the Landmarks Preservation Commission office,  1 Centre Street, 9th floor, on May 1st followed by a Public Hearing on Tuesday, May 5th, starting at 9:30 am.  If you are interested please come, see for yourself, and most importantly, speak to the LPC on May 5th about the importance of maintaining the character of this historic neighborhood.

1 Comment

Filed under Local Real Estate

David McCullough article in Newsweek

Pulitzer-Prize winning author David McCullough expresses his views regarding the planned tower adjacent to the Brooklyn Bridge in this week’s Newsweek edition.

http://www.newsweek.com/id/194596/

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project

David McCullough Brooklyn Bridge video op-ed on Youtube

David McCullough speaks out against the planned Dock Street tower adjacent to the Brooklyn Bridge in this video, view it here. You can also read more about it at about.com.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project

Squadron Park Financing Plan: No Housing, but still huge hotel?

An outline of Senator Squadron’s innovative Brooklyn Bridge Park financing plan has been published on his website. We have downloaded it for your review here as well. Although his plan calls for the removal of the planned additional housing in the Park, it leaves the hotel as part of the Pier 1 plans. FFLA continues to advocate for a smaller hotel complex, conforming to the footprint of the Cold Storage building, rather than the 5-block long structures in the current BBPDC plans. brooklyn_bridge_park_presentation_final_draft

Leave a Comment

Filed under Brooklyn Bridge Park

Speculation Grows for Witnessing Further JW Exits

Over the past few years the Watchtower Society, also known as Jehovah’s Witnesses, have sold off several properties in Brooklyn Heights, most notably 360 Furman, now known as  One Brooklyn Bridge Park. Recently, it was reported that the Witnesses have purchased 291 acres in Rockland County, with plans for a live/work complex to accommodate 850 of their members. This has led to speculation that they might sell the former Squibb Pharmaceutical buildings on Columbia Heights, or the buildings on Sands Street. Alternatively, they could choose not to build the proposed dormitory on the Jay Street superblock in DUMBO. At this point it is too early to know anything for sure, so don’t count on the Squibb buildings as potential condos to fund Brooklyn Bridge Park just yet. Read more in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, if you can make it past the triple negative in the first sentence, that is.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Brooklyn Bridge Park, Local Real Estate

David McCullough holds press conference in DUMBO, calls project “visual vandalism”

Historian and author David McCullough held a press conference in DUMBO this morning, arranged by the DUMBO Neighborhood Association. He spoke at length and very passionately about the desecration that would occur should Dock Street DUMBO be built as planned. You can read more in the New York Times and the Brooklyn Daily Eagle and Newsday. See original announcement at DUMBONYC.

Update 4/2/2009: Additional coverage at NY1 and at the Brooklyn Paper and at the Daily News.

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project

NY Post reports on Dept of Ed backroom dealings with Walentas, money trail to pols

An article today in the New York Post reported what we and the local Brooklyn blogs and papers published last week, that suspect dealings took place during the latter half of 2008 between the DOE and DUMBO developer Two Trees. The article goes further in revealing the extent of the lobbying ( over $400,000 spent in the past 2 years) including campaign donations to Council Speaker Christine Quinn and Councilwoman and Land Use Chair Melinda Katz (See article from City Hall News).

Leave a Comment

Filed under Dock Street Project